let it all collapse, the icon for the www.punkerslut.com website
Home Articles Critiques Books Video
About Graphics CopyLeft Links Music

Authority: Political and Economic

Anarcho-Capitalism,
Considered by an Anarcho-Socialist

By Punkerslut

From RadicalGraphics.org
Image: From "Money" Gallery from RadicalGraphics.org

Start Date: June 1, 2009
Finish Date: June 1, 2009

"...the absolute independence of the individual. That is what we want. I want it so that I, one of the children of Nature, can stand on an equality with the rest; that I can say this is MY air, MY sunshine, MY earth, and I have a right to live, and hope and aspire, and labor, and enjoy the fruit of that labor, as much as any individual or any nation on the face of the globe."
          --Robert Green Ingersoll, 1876
          "Centennial Oration"

     Politically, the ideas of Anarcho-Capitalism and Anarcho-Collectivism share some of the same traits. Even given that fact that we both oppose the state, there are still strong differences between -- philosophically as well as ideologically.

     First, I am opposed to authority, wherever it may appear in society. I oppose it politically and legally, where one seeks to impose their "enlightening will" on others around them, using violence and coercion. But I also oppose it economically.

"...the absolute independence of the individual. That is what we want. I want it so that I, one of the children of Nature, can stand on an equality with the rest; that I can say this is MY air, MY sunshine, MY earth, and I have a right to live, and hope and aspire, and labor, and enjoy the fruit of that labor, as much as any individual or any nation on the face of the globe."
          --Peter Kropotkin, 1892
          "The Conquest of Bread," Chapter 1, Part III

     If your boss reduces your hours, uses dangerous machinery, or cuts your wages, they are practicing their authority against you. Yes, you do have the freedom to leave, and to take on another boss as the authority against you economically. You also have the liberty to starve -- to go out, quietly, painfully, and alone, as your way of resisting this miserable system.

     In this, I find the perfect analogy of the state -- or, more deeply, the concept of a social authority. Yes, you can quit the state, whenever you'd like, but then you're under the immediate obligation of finding another state to become your ruler. And if this is too much for you, you have other liberties as well -- you can reject your government, its laws, its violence, and end up in prison or the gallows.

"A few rich people own the lands and machines. The many labor and have nothing. This every worker knows."
          --William D. Haywood, with Frank Bohn, ~Early 1900's
          "Industrial Socialism," Part 2: Industrial Progress

     Yes, there is a liberty in Capitalism and the State. To the Capitalist, I can change my master (to an equally oppressive master), or to the state, I can change and move to another country. But no matter how often I move, I find the same thing -- the Dutch, French, African, and Korean governments are all the same! Likewise, I found that the Capitalist is as greedy, violent, and oppressive in Nepal as they are in Argentina.

     And there is always the freedom to withdraw. You can avoid enforcement of the law, but you need to be in a prison! Oh, and you can also avoid the exploitation of a Capitalist system, but you need to be starving in the streets!

"We have declared war upon the capitalist class, and upon the capitalist system. We are of the working class. We say: Arouse, you workingmen! It is in your power to put an end to this system. It is your duty to build up this great revolutionary economic organization of your class, to seize and take control of the tools with which you work, and make yourselves the masters instead of being the slaves of industry."
          --Eugene V. Debs, 1905
          "Class Unionism"

     So, either way, to put a bullet in a man's head, or to deny him the right to work for bread, either way -- you kill the human being in the process. Stalin's "wheat confiscation" in the Ukraine is responsible to nearly ten million deaths, but I can't say that it accomplished anything different than the militarist aggression used in Poland, Czech, Afghanistan, and Korea.

     I'm Anarcho-Syndicalist because of this fundamental reason: authority, whether it is born in a government or a capitalist, is a menace to human happiness and liberty.

Punkerslut,


Punkerslut
join the punkerslut.com
mailing list!

Punkerslut
copyleft notice and
responsibility disclaimer